Blog

Simon Smith, Chief Economist

Welcome to the point of no return

16/05/12 @ 12:44 GMT by Simon Smith, Chief Economist

Nearly five years into the global credit crunch, you get a feeling for when something has reached the point of no return, when no amount of reassurance, promises or policies will fight the tide of markets. But to be sure, this is not to define markets as pure ‘speculators’, rather rational individuals and entities that are removing deposits from Greek banks, reducing their exposures to all types of market risk and doing their best not to be crushed by a moving train.

The moving train is, of course, Greece. As well as reports of large scale withdrawals from Greek banks, we’ve had (unconfirmed, then denied) reports that the ECB is also refusing liquidity requests from Greek banks, pushing them to the Greek central bank because of the lack of recapitalisation undertaken. We’ve seen sharp increases in forward Libor-OIS spreads, the measure of interbank liquidity risk that was so watched during the early days of the crisis. From being taboo in official circles, a Greek exit is now more openly being discussed, rather than dismissed outright.

At the same time, after two years of fire-fighting the Greek and wider sovereign crises, there is no policy response that can credibly stem the tide. We’ve had two large scale EU/IMF rescue packages, a tortuous ‘voluntary’ private sector-restructuring and vast lending form the ECB (with ever lower collateral standards applied). The more credible response now from the authorities would be measures to stem contagion elsewhere, particularly with respect to bank deposits in other eurozone countries now that permitted cross-border lending between deposit-guarantee schemes will not be workable

.

Contagion remains the biggest single risk, given that a Greek exit will mean that what was previously presented as irreversible and unthinkable will have become reality. This is where efforts now need to be focused, otherwise the single currency will be left horribly exposed by a Greek exit. Furthermore, all efforts to ‘save’ Greece from here on in will have been wasted and at the cost of failing to deal with the contagion issue. Policy-makers face a critical choice this week. Let’s hope they choose the right one.

Tags: Greece

Michael Derks, Chief Strategist

More RMB depreciation cannot be ruled out

15/05/12 @ 09:19 GMT by Michael Derks, Chief Strategist

Noticeable over recent months is that all those commentators and talking heads who have claimed for so long that China’s currency is massively undervalued have gone into hibernation. Because what has become abundantly clear is that the analysis that lay behind this claim was fundamentally flawed and incomplete. Recent developments in China will now hopefully trigger a more rational appraisal of the valuation of the currency, which so far this year has actually depreciated against the dollar, the pound and other major Asian currencies (except for the Japanese yen). Indeed, given the deteriorating state of the economy, further RMB depreciation cannot be ruled out.

Two main forces have been weighing on the renminbi:

Firstly, the economy is enduring a much rockier landing than expected. Most striking has been the stream of consistently weak key domestic economic indicators such as electricity production, rail cargo volumes, residential floor space construction, land sales and house prices. Business investment, a huge contributor to the Chinese growth story over recent years, has slowed markedly, hurt by declining global demand, higher operating costs and reduced profitability.

Policy officials have been a little slow to respond to the deteriorating growth picture, perhaps distracted by the upheaval and political machinations within the Politburo. That said, policy-makers have enormous scope to stimulate the economy as and when they feel it is necessary; bank reserve requirements remain extremely high (notwithstanding the recent 50bp reduction), fiscal policy has a lot of potential to provide the economy with a powerful boost and key interest rates can be lowered significantly (although only once the inflation genie has been contained). With domestic demand-growth clearly more tentative it is not surprising that foreign capital-inflow has slowed markedly and that the currency is no longer rising.

Secondly, those Chinese who have amassed wealth in the country over the past decade are becoming much more active in attempting to convert their bounty into hard currencies. Conscious that conditions in their own country are not nearly as favourable, high net worth investors have been transferring their wealth to safer havens such as property in major global cities, dollars, Japanese yen and the pound. In London, a major explanation for the rise in property values over the past year or so is the dominating presence of cashed-up Chinese buyers. Over the next couple of years, we can expect a lot more of this type of activity which will put downward pressure on the Chinese currency.

From a political perspective, Beijing will be aware that a depreciating currency will create huge tensions, especially with the US. Also, China’s massive foreign exchange reserves could be used to thwart any downward pressure on the currency.

At the very least, the indifferent display by the renminbi this year has neutralised expectations regarding future currency performance. Presently, the forward market actually anticipates that the yuan will fall by 1% over the next year. As we have been suggesting for some time now, during such a turbulent year, and not just economically and financially but also politically, Beijing was always likely to favour a relatively stable exchange rate.

Tags: CNY

Simon Smith, Chief Economist

Finding the inflexion point

14/05/12 @ 12:01 GMT by Simon Smith, Chief Economist

Whilst the single currency has certainly suffered so far this month, by all accounts it’s not yet reached an inflexion point whereby it’s fallen out of bed. Yes, it remains true that EUR/USD has fallen in all but two trading days so far this month, but at the same time it’s the high-beta currencies that have taken more of the pain, the Aussie, Kiwi, scandis and Mexican peso all losing ground against the euro. On this basis it looks to be more a global re-rating of risk, of which the euro crisis is playing its part, but this will more likely than not change in the near future.

At the present moment, Greece is still trying to form a government, more than a week after the election result. Belgium managed for well over a year in 2010/11 without a formal government, but Greece can’t be afforded the same leeway. There are two choices. Either a coalition is formed from the current make-up of parties, or fresh elections are called, most likely for next month. Even if a government is stitched together in the coming days however, it’s unlikely to be strong enough to appease international lenders such as the EU and IMF.

What we have seen so far this month are some notable shifts though, most of which fail to fight against the possibility of Greece exiting the euro. This prospect has been openly aired by some ECB members, a key shift from the previous stance of not countenancing such a possibility. In addition, last week the IMF announced it was adding to its reserve in the face of the growing credit risk it’s facing.

At the same time, there were hints from Germany that it may be prepared to tolerate higher inflation, playing its part in reducing the competitive imbalances that are near the core of the euro crisis. On the face of it, this has been seen as a major shift in German thinking, not least given the long-held desire to run monetary policy in the eurozone along German lines. But, put into context, this shift is too little and too late in terms of offering an exit route from the sovereign crisis.

Right now, we face two possible inflexion points. The first is when Germany and the ECB relent and effectively ditch the ‘no bail-out’ clause that has been enshrined from the start of the single currency. In other words, allowing countries to assume the debts of others, via whatever means. The second is when markets reach the point where they believe the EU and international lenders have run out of road in terms of their ability to keep the single currency together. At this point, the euro would not only weaken, it would weaken against even the high-beta currencies. We’ve not reached either inflexion point yet, but the second is looking a lot nearer, more likely and more credible, both economically and politically.

Tags: eur

Michael Derks, Chief Strategist

Spanish banks – the next systemic risk

10/05/12 @ 09:46 GMT by Michael Derks, Chief Strategist

Yesterday’s decision by the Rajoy government to take a 45% stake in troubled lender Bankia and to provide capital as necessary is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of cleaning up the bereft Spanish banking system. The third-largest lender in Spain and arguably the most vulnerable because of its huge exposure to the tumbling property market, the government correctly formed the view that urgent steps were required to attempt to stabilise Bankia.

Unfortunately, the extent of non-performing property loans sitting on Spanish bank balance sheets is ballooning at an alarming pace. Earlier this year, the government demanded that lenders raise their loan-loss provisions by a further EUR 54bn to EUR 155bn. However, according to the Bank of Spain, this will only cover roughly half of the loans made to property developers, without any provisioning for the huge EUR 1.45trln of mortgages and corporate debt on bank books. Indeed, research by the Centre for Policy Studies claims that proper provisioning for non-performing loans in these two categories would entail banks setting aside a further EUR 270bn.

If the Spanish government attempted to fill this gap, it would lift the debt/GDP ratio from near 70% currently to around 120%. To make matters worse, flush with ECB cash, local banks have increased their purchases of Spanish bonds by a third in recent months. As such, if bad debts at banks continue to grow (a given), and the government is forced to inject funds (money is does not have), then the public debt grows exponentially and the sovereign’s solvency is threatened, further undermining the bank’s position. With the economy stuck in a deep recession and borrowing costs quite elevated, Spain would rapidly find itself trapped in a deadly debt spiral, requiring huge financial assistance from the EU and the IMF.

The frightening consequence is that, if the latter come to the party and helped Spain out it would virtually exhaust their financial resources. Little wonder that risk assets are tremulating once more.

Tags: Spain

Michael Derks, Chief Strategist

Why is the euro not much lower?

09/05/12 @ 08:50 GMT by Michael Derks, Chief Strategist

It is looking decidedly dreadful for the single currency once again.

In Greece, the leader of the far-left Syriza party, which gained 17% of the votes at the weekend election, has given the two major parties an ultimatum demanding that they renounce the commitment they gave European leaders to implement austerity measures. This latest bout of political paralysis comes at a critical time as Greece needs to decide imminently whether it will pay interest on a JPY 20bn note and pay back the principal on a EUR 436m floating-rate note. Unsurprisingly, speculation is rising that Greece is likely to leave the euro before the end of this year.

In Spain, it is clear that the economy is experiencing a very deep recession, which is severely compromising efforts to recapitalise the troubled banking sector. With property prices in virtual freefall, the EUR 340bn exposure to property developers being carried by these banks almost guarantees that most will require very large capital injections, some of which will inevitably come from the government which itself cannot afford to assist.

In France, new president Hollande wants to tear up Europe’s new fiscal compact, tapping into popular disenchantment across the Continent with Germany’s insistence on perpetual fiscal austerity. Suddenly, Germany, the strong man of Europe and its financial guardian, looks increasingly isolated.

Against the backdrop of these very negative developments, and with renewed doubts being expressed over the whole euro project’s ability to survive, it is worth asking just why the single currency is not a lot lower. Overnight, the euro has fallen back under 1.30, but to put this into context it was trading down at 1.27 in mid January. Indeed, for the year to date, the euro has outperformed the US dollar, the Japanese yen and the Aussie, although it is lagging behind a resurgent pound. This is hardly the performance of a currency of which investors and traders fear for its longevity.

Attempting to explain this remarkably tepid price response to what most would concede has been a period of deteriorating fundamentals is a critical task. Firstly, it is worth recognising that these concerns regarding the euro’s longer-term viability have been around for the past two years and, as such, investors and traders alike have had plenty of time to adjust their allocations. Be they sovereign wealth funds, real money managers, high net worth investors or traders, all have likely taken much of the evasive action that they need to. For example, traders’ short positions remain extremely elevated although there has been some short-covering over recent months.

Secondly, although the process has been incredibly lengthy and convoluted, Europe has fashioned together a reasonable response to its sovereign debt and banking crisis. The ECB has been prepared to provide Europe’s ailing banks with extremely cheap liquidity, Europe’s governments have signed up to a strengthened fiscal pact, the EFSF and ESM have been established to provide financial assistance to troubled sovereigns and many European governments are implementing much-needed fiscal austerity and structural reform.

As such, the fairly muted response by the currency to this latest buffet of bad news likely reflects the fact that Europe’s ills are already well-recognised, and moreover that the process of repair is now underway.

Indeed, there is a warning here for euro bears, namely the inability of the single currency to sustain downward momentum on bad news.

Tags: eureurozone